23057 Bluegill Lane, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042 (MLS# B26062448)

23057 Bluegill Lane, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042

$1,350,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 3 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 3,136 Status: Closed
Current Price: $1,350,000 List Date: 8/10/2026 Last Modified: 11/05/2026

Overview

Description

Look no further--this exceptional property truly has it all. This beautifully maintained CBS home boasts open-water views and is situated on an oversized lot on an extra-wide, deep canal, great for bigger boats, and just three houses in from the end. You'll be up on plane in seconds, with unparalleled boating access to both the Atlantic and Gulf. Ideally located closest to the premier backcountry of the Lower Florida Keys, this is the perfect property for the fishing and diving enthusiasts and still only 20 minutes to Key West. Built by Tom Ryan Construction, this solid CBS 3-bedroom 2-bath home is almost 1,300 square feet, and has a spacious, open feel, created by the thoughtful layout and vaulted ceilings in the main living area.

Supplements: The kitchen features granite countertops, a convenient breakfast bar, and a dedicated dining area, making it ideal for both everyday island living and entertaining. The primary suite has a walk in closet and french doors leading out to the porch, while the second bedroom has a pocket door creating another convenient ensuite for guests. Most days y ...

Listing Details MLS# B26062448

General Property Information

Property Sub Type
Single Family Residence
Bedrooms Total
3
Bathrooms Total
2
Bathrooms Full
2
Building Area Main
3136
Building Area Source
Public Records
Living Area Main
1270
Living Area Source
Public Records
Accessibility Features YN
No
Year Built
1997
Garage YN
Yes
Attached Garage YN
Yes
Garage Spaces
Yes
Carport YN
Yes
Attached Carport YN
Yes
Carport Spaces
2
Covered Spaces
3
Parking Total
6
Gated Community YN
No
Lot Size Area
10200
Lot Size Acres
0.23
Senior Community YN
No
Waterfront YN
Yes
Water Frontage Feet
85
Outdoor Living Spaces YN
Yes
Stories Total
2
Stories
2
Direction Faces
South
Fireplace YN
No
Pool Private YN
No
Green Verification YN
No
Furnished
Negotiable
Year Roof Installed
2018
LP/Assessed Value
4.26

Property Features

Dining Area: Breakfast Area; Kitchen Dining; Snack Bar/Counter Flooring: Carpet; Tile Foundation Details: Block; Slab Leasing Permitted Details: Okay To Lease; Okay To Lease With Restrictions Parking Features: Covered; Open; Attached Carport; Attached Garage; Carport; Garage Property Condition: Resale Special Listing Conditions: Standard Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Electric Range; Microwave; Oven; Refrigerator; Washer; Water Heater Water Heater Details: Electric Water Heater Architectural Style: Contemporary; Stilt Boat and Dock Features: Electric Available; Private Dock; Water Available Construction Materials: CBS; Concrete Cooling: Central Air; Electric Heating: Central; Electric Interior Features: Entrance Foyer Laundry Features: Laundry Closet Levels: One Listing Terms: 1031 Exchange; Cash; Conventional; FHA; VA Loan Lot Features: Fruit Tree(s); Landscaped; Oversized Lot; Room for Pool Main Living Area: Upstairs Other Structures: Workshop Pets Allowed YN: Yes Pets Allowed: No Restrictions Possession: Close Of Escrow Restrictions: Lease Restrictions Other Leasing Restrictions: Short Term Rentals Prohibited Road Frontage Type: County Road Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road Road Surface Type: Asphalt Roof: Metal Sewer: Public Sewer Special Information: Flood Zone; Property Survey Available Storm Protection Details: Storm Shutters Structure Type: House Tax Information: Homestead Exemption Utilities: Cable Available; Electricity Available; Natural Gas Not Available; Sewer Connected; Water Connected View: Water Water Access: No Fixed Bridge; Ocean Access Water Source: Public Water View: Bay; Canal Waterfront Features: Canal Front; Navigable Water; Seawall Canal Width: Canal Width 1-80 Feet Window Features: Jalousie; Shutters Showing Requirements: Call Listing Agent; Listing Agent Must Accompany; Occupied; Sign On Property; Text Listing Agent Outdoor Living Spaces: Porch Porch Details: Porch - Screened Contingencies: Financing; Inspection Room Types: Kitchen; Living Room; Master Bedroom Acreage Description: Less Than 1/4 Acre Lot; Less Than 1 Acre Lot

Contract Information

Comp Sale YN
No
Original List Price
1349000
Negotiable Seller Concessions YN
No
Occupant Type
Owner
Listing Service
Full Service
Seller Represented YN
Yes

Location and Legal

Country
United States
County Or Parish
Monroe
Street Number
23057
Street Name
Bluegill
Street Suffix
Lane
Municipality Type
Unincorporated
State Or Province
FL
Postal Code
33042
Postal Code +4
4705
Subdivision Name
CUDJOE OCEAN SHORES AMD SEC 2A
Area
5940 - Other Florida County
Geographic Area
Other
Elementary School
Sugarloaf
Middle Or Junior School
Sugarloaf
High School
Key West
Special Assessment YN
No
Parcel Number
00188684003400
Zoning
is
Flood Zone
AE
Directions
Turn north onto Cutthroat Drive in Cudjoe Key at MM 23 then make a right onto Bluegill Lane. House is the 3 in from the end on the left.
Multiple Offers Accepted
Yes

Financial Information

Application Required YN
No
Master Association YN
No
Membership Fee Required YN
No
Tax Annual Amount
3138.35
Tax Year
2025
Tax Assessed/SOH Value
316638
Tax Legal Description
BK 10 LT 16 AMENDED PLAT CUDJOE OCEAN SHORES SECTION TWO-A CUDJOE KEY PB6-76
Assessor Market Value
950612

Status Change Information

Major Change Timestamp
2026-11-05T11:24:43Z
Major Change Type
Status Change
Status Change Date
2026-11-05
Under Contract Date
2026-09-09
Close Date
2026-10-30
Close Price
1350000
Buyer Financing
Conventional

More Information

Leasing Permitted Details

Leasing Permitted YN
Yes

Boat and Dock Information

Dock
Yes

Capital Contributions

Capital Contributions YN
No

Co-Ownership

Property Management YN
No

Main Level Rooms

Main Level Bathrooms
2
Main Level Bedrooms
3

Pet Details

Pet Fee YN
No

Leasing Restrictions

Leasing - Max Times Per Year
12
Leasing - Minimum Number of Days
28

Storm Protection

Accordian Shutters
Partial
Other Protection
Partial

Price Calculations

Current Price To SqFt
1062.2

Originating Details

Originating System Key
20260810174119719677000000
Originating System ID
M00000170

Room Information

Room Name
Kitchen
Living Room
Master Bedroom
IDX
Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real E
Source MLS Verified
Last Updated: November - 05 - 2026
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. Copyright 2026 Beaches Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. Information Not Guaranteed and Must Be Confirmed by End User. Site contains live data.